This post is inspired by a piece in the October 29, 2016 edition of the “New Scientist” by an article titled, “Lying feels bad at first but our brains soon adapt to deceiving.” The article reported an experiment run by Tali Sharot of University College London and her team. This experiment encouraged volunteers to lie. They were shown jars of pennies filled in varying degrees and asked to send estimates of how many there were to partners in another room. The partners were shown blurrier images of the jar, so they relied on the volunteers’ estimates to guess the number of pennies in order to win a reward for each of them.
The volunteers were told that they would get a higher personal reward if their partner’s answer were wrong, and that the more inaccurate the answer, the greater the reward would be. They started telling lies, which were small at first but then escalated. For example a person who might have started with a lie that earned them one pound sterling, might have ended up telling fibs worth eight pounds sterling.
Brain scans showed that the first lie was associated with a burst of activity in the amygdalae, which are involved in emotional responding. But this activity lessened as the lies progressed (Nature Neuroscience, DOI: 10.1038/nn.4426).
Donald Trump has had a long career lying, and his lies have rewarded him well. HM doubts if there is any activity in his amygdalae when he lies. Trump’s lies frequently contradict each other, so it is clear that he fails to remember lies. The question is whether he is even aware that he is lying. When confronted with the truth, including unequivocal evidence of the truth, he still denies it. He invents conspiracies, which he apparently believes. At first he complained that the Republican primary was rigged. If so, it was rigged in his favor. Now he threatens to disavow the results of the presidential election should he not be elected. One concludes from this that Trump lives in an alternative reality, one which is largely divorced from reality. A president who is divorced from reality would be disastrous.
Unfortunately, political polls have indicated that many have chosen to join Trump in his alternative reality. This is frightening for democracy, and the size of the Trump vote will provide a good index of how frightened we should be.
One of the many ironies of this presidential election, is that Hillary Clinton is accused of lying and voters say that they do not believe her. First of all, she is a politician. Although the term politician has negative connotations, politicians are essential to a working democracy. Saying that Hillary Clinton has lied is as enlightening as saying the Pope is a Catholic. Even Honest Abe Lincoln lied. Fact checkers have been monitoring both candidates. Comparing Hillary Clinton to Donald Trump regarding lies is like comparing the Chicago fire (Trump) to someone in his back yard burning leaves (Clinton).
Here is a link well worth clicking:
© Douglas Griffith and healthymemory.wordpress.com, 2016. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this blog’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to Douglas Griffith and healthymemory.wordpress.com with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.